So you've heard about Alice in the Looking Glass and wonder what all the fuss is about? Maybe you saw the movie poster or stumbled upon references in pop culture. Truth is, there's way more to Alice in the Looking Glass than meets the eye. It's not just a sequel or some random fantasy tale – it's where math meets madness and wordplay becomes weaponized. I remember first reading it in college and thinking "Wait, is this nonsense or pure genius?" (Spoiler: it's both).
What Actually Is Alice in the Looking Glass?
Let's cut through the confusion right away. Alice in the Looking Glass typically refers to Lewis Carroll's 1871 novel "Through the Looking-Glass, and What Alice Found There". But here's where people get tripped up – it's NOT the same as "Alice's Adventures in Wonderland" (that's the first book with the rabbit hole). The looking glass version flips everything: chessboards replace card games, time bends backward, and nursery rhyme characters come to life.
The Original Book (1871)
Written by mathematician Charles Dodgson under pen name Lewis Carroll. Inspired by real girl Alice Liddell. Full of chess symbolism, mirror logic puzzles, and poems like "Jabberwocky" that broke English language rules. I tried reading it to my niece last year – she loved Tweedledee but the chess stuff went over her head.
The 2016 Movie
Directed by James Bobin, produced by Tim Burton. Stars Mia Wasikowska as Alice, Johnny Depp as Mad Hatter. While marketed as book adaptation, honestly? It borrows characters but invents new plot about time travel. Critics slammed it (29% on Rotten Tomatoes), but visually stunning. Saw it in theaters – costumes deserved awards even if script didn't.
Key Differences Between Book and Film
| Aspect | 1871 Book | 2016 Movie |
|---|---|---|
| Core Story | Alice crosses mirror into chess-based world | Alice travels through time to save Hatter |
| Villain | No clear villain (Red Queen is antagonist) | Time (Sacha Baron Cohen) as personified enemy |
| Humpty Dumpty | Major character with wordplay scenes | Completely absent from film |
| Cultural Impact | Introduced phrases like "chortle" and "galumphing" | Box office disappointment ($299M vs $1B for first film) |
Where to Experience Alice in the Looking Glass Today
Want to dive in? Here's how normal people actually access Alice Through the Looking Glass content without hunting rare books or torrents:
Reading the Original Book
Good news: it's public domain. Project Gutenberg has free versions. But paper beats pixels for this one – the logical puzzles work better when you can flip pages back and forth. Oxford World's Classics edition has killer footnotes explaining Carroll's math jokes.
| Edition Type | Where to Get | Price Range | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Budget Paperback | Amazon, Barnes & Noble | $5-$8 | Casual readers |
| Illustrated Collector's | Independent bookstores | $25-$40 | Art lovers (Tenniel illustrations are iconic) |
| Annotated Version | University bookstores | $35-$60 | Serious fans (explains Victorian jokes) |
Watching the 2016 Film
The Alice Through the Looking Glass movie got buried fast after release. Currently streaming on Disney+ in most regions. If you rent on Amazon Prime or YouTube, expect to pay $3.99 for HD. Blu-ray collectors edition includes deleted scenes showing more of Time's castle – actually more interesting than main plot.
Fair warning: Don't expect faithful adaptation. The film uses Carroll's characters for completely new story. Helena Bonham Carter chews scenery as Red Queen though – she's having way too much fun. I mean, who wouldn't want to play a character with giant tomato head?
Why This Story Still Matters (Seriously)
Beyond fancy costumes and Depp's weird makeup, Alice in the Looking Glass tackles mind-bending concepts that scientists now study:
- Mirror Logic - The book explores how reality distorts in reflections. Modern physics actually deals with this in quantum theory.
- Time as Character - Carroll plays with time reversals decades before Einstein. The movie makes Time a literal person (weird choice but bold).
- Language Games - Humpty Dumpty's speech about words meaning whatever he chooses predicts linguistic theories by 50+ years.
"When I use a word," Humpty Dumpty said, in rather a scornful tone, "it means just what I choose it to mean—neither more nor less."
— Lewis Carroll, Through the Looking-Glass
That quote changed how I think about communication. Lawyers must love this guy.
Common Questions People Actually Ask
Working at a bookstore for three years, I've heard every Alice in the Looking Glass question imaginable. Here are the real ones:
Is Alice in Wonderland and Alice in the Looking Glass the same?
Nope. Different books, different worlds. Wonderland has playing cards and rabbit holes. Looking-Glass has chessboards and mirror logic. The 2010 Burton movie mashed them together though.
Why is the 2016 movie called Alice Through the Looking Glass if it's not faithful?
Marketing, plain and simple. After first film made $1 billion, they slapped the famous title on an unrelated script. Should've called it "Alice vs. Time" or something. My film student friend rants about this weekly.
What's up with the backwards writing?
In Chapter 1, Alice reads "JABBERWOCKY" in mirror-writing. Carroll was obsessed with symmetry. You can actually buy reversible editions that include mirror for reading.
Is this appropriate for kids?
Book: depends on kid. Some love nonsense poems, others get frustrated. Movie: safer but has intense moments. My cousin's 7-year-old had nightmares about Time's hourglass minions.
Hidden Gems Most Guides Miss
Typical Alice in the Looking Glass articles recycle the same facts. Here's what they skip:
The Mathematical Easter Eggs
Carroll (real name Charles Dodgson) taught math at Oxford. The entire book follows chess movement rules: Alice is pawn moving to 8th square to become queen. Each chapter corresponds to chess piece movement. Mind blown yet?
Real Locations You Can Visit
• Christ Church, Oxford: Staircase where Carroll first told stories to Alice Liddell
• Antique shop in London (inspired chapter 5) - actually based on real store near Oxford
• "The Sheep Shop" from chapter 5 still operates in Oxford (45 St Aldate's)
Visited Oxford last spring – the sheep shop sells overpriced souvenirs but cool atmosphere.
Modern Adaptations Worth Your Time
| Title | Format | Why It Stands Out |
|---|---|---|
| Alice: Madness Returns | Video Game | Dark psychological take on looking-glass logic |
| Looking-Glass Girl | Novel (2016) | Modern boarding school mystery using Carroll themes |
| Royal Ballet Production | Stage Performance | Uses chessboard stage & reversed choreography |
Why the Tim Burton Film Divided Fans
Let's address the elephant in the room. The Alice Through the Looking Glass movie has 29% critic score but 51% audience score on Rotten Tomatoes. Having watched it three times (once for review, twice to confirm my feelings), here's the real breakdown:
What Works
• Costume design (won Saturn Award)
• Sacha Baron Cohen as Time
• Visual effects - especially fluid clock sequences
• Danny Elfman's score
What Doesn't
• Contrived emotional backstories
• Wasted characters (Anne Hathaway barely there)
• Confusing time travel rules
• Feels like corporate sequel rather than passion project
Honestly? The first hour shows promise when exploring Time's castle. Then it becomes formulaic. Still worth watching for Helena Bonham Carter's delivery of "I'm choking on my own rage!"
Making Sense of the Madness: Study Resources
Feeling lost in the looking-glass world? These helped me grasp Carroll's genius:
- The Annotated Alice by Martin Gardner (essential companion book)
- Symbolic Logic YouTube series by Carneades.org (breaks down Carroll's logic puzzles)
- Oxford University's free online Carroll archives (handwritten drafts with margin notes)
- Chess.com's "Alice Chess" variant tutorial (yes, it's a real game format)
Pro tip: Read chapters aloud. The rhythm of nonsense makes more sense when spoken. Did this during lockdown – neighbors probably thought I'd cracked.
Beyond the Hype: Should You Bother?
After all this, is Alice in the Looking Glass worth your time? As someone who's analyzed both book and film extensively:
The Book: Absolutely. It's shorter than you think (under 200 pages). The wordplay holds up, though some Victorian jokes need explaining. Skip if you hate puzzles or ambiguity.
The Movie: Only if you loved first Burton film OR are costume design nerd. Temper expectations – it's eye candy with plot holes. Could've been great Minions-style short film about Time's minions though.
Final thought? Carroll's looking-glass world reflects our own in unsettling ways. The rules make no sense until you realize... maybe reality's rules are just as arbitrary. Deep for a children's book? Exactly.
Leave a Comments