Honestly, whenever someone asks me "what is the best midsize SUV," I want to ask them 10 questions first. Are you hauling kids or kayaks? Do you care more about saving gas money or having a quiet ride? I learned this the hard way when I recommended my neighbor a Toyota Highlander for its reliability, only to hear her complain for months about the stiff seats during her highway commute. Let's cut through the marketing fluff and talk real-world use.
First Things First: What Actually Counts as a Midsize SUV?
Car makers love stretching definitions. Here’s my rule of thumb: If it fits between 185-200 inches long, has three rows (or spacious two rows), and can tow at least 3,500 lbs, it’s midsize. Compact SUVs like the Honda CR-V feel cramped for families, while full-size monsters like the Chevy Suburban require a parking pilot license. The sweet spot? Think Honda Pilot, Hyundai Palisade, or Ford Explorer territory.
Key Measurements That Matter
| Category | Typical Range | Why You Should Care |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Length | 186"- 198" | Fits in standard garages/parking spots (unlike full-size) |
| Cargo Space (3rd row folded) | 45-85 cu. ft | Weekend Costco runs vs. family road trip luggage |
| Towing Capacity | 3,500 - 5,000 lbs | Small boat or trailer? Check this twice |
| Ground Clearance | 7.5"- 8.5" | Snowy driveways vs. curb hopping at the mall |
Note: Some "compact" models like the Grand Cherokee stretch definitions – measure your garage first!
The 5 Crucial Tests for Any Best Midsize SUV Contender
After test-driving 12 models last year, here’s what actually impacts daily life:
Non-Negotiables
- Car Seat Tetris: Can you fit rear-facing seats without sacrificing the driver’s legroom? (Toyota Highlander fails this)
- Real-World MPG: Subtract 3-5 mpg from EPA estimates (turbo engines drink more in traffic)
- Blind Spot Monsters: Test visibility at dusk with rain on windows (I nearly sideswiped a motorcycle in a Kia Telluride)
Overrated Features
- 0-60 Times: Unless you’re towing, 7-9 seconds is plenty
- Off-Road Modes: Most never leave pavement (save $2k+ on packages)
- Gesture Controls: Cool demo, frustrating daily use (looking at you, BMW!)
2024’s Top Contenders Ranked (With Brutal Honesty)
Here’s the truth: The best midsize SUV changes based on your needs. But if I had to rank them today:
| Model | Best For | Where It Disappoints | Real MPG (Mixed) | Base Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hyundai Palisade | Families needing space/value | Vague steering feel | 21-23 mpg | $37,800 |
| Honda Pilot | Resale value/reliability | Noisy cabin at 70mph | 22-24 mpg | $39,900 |
| Jeep Grand Cherokee | Off-road capability | Expensive repairs post-warranty | 19-21 mpg | $41,000 |
| Ford Explorer | Towing (5,300 lbs) | Clunky infotainment | 20-22 mpg | $39,000 |
| Subaru Ascent | Snowy climates | Weak CVT acceleration | 23-25 mpg | $35,800 |
Surprised the Toyota Highlander isn’t here? Their 2024 refresh removed captain’s chairs in lower trims – a dealbreaker for minivan refugees. Sometimes newer isn’t better.
Cost Breakdown: Where the Money Actually Goes
Dealer markups hide nasty surprises. Here’s what you’ll really pay over 5 years:
| Expense Type | Hyundai Palisade | Ford Explorer | Honda Pilot |
|---|---|---|---|
| Purchase Price (Mid-trim) | $44,600 | $46,200 | $47,300 |
| 5-Year Fuel Cost* | $11,400 | $12,800 | $11,100 |
| Insurance Premiums | $7,200 | $8,100 | $6,900 |
| Projected Repairs | $1,800 | $3,500 | $2,100 |
| Total 5-Year Cost | $65,000 | $70,600 | $67,400 |
*Based on 15,000 miles/year at current fuel prices. Repair data from Consumer Reports.
See why "sticker price" is misleading? The best midsize SUV for budget buyers is rarely the cheapest upfront.
Safety Deep Dive: IIHS Scores Don't Tell the Whole Story
All 2024 midsizers have automatic braking, but real-world safety differs wildly:
- Headlight Performance: Subaru Ascent’s LED projectors illuminate 450 feet – Honda Pilot’s halogens barely reach 300 ft (scary on rural roads)
- Child Seat Anchors: Toyota Highlander’s LATCH system requires yoga moves to access
- Rear Occupant Alerts: Kia/Hyundai detect movement in back seats (prevents child/dog heatstroke)
My recommendation? Never skip the $1,200 premium headlight upgrade. Deer don’t care about your crash ratings.
Overlooked Safety Features Worth Paying For
- Rear Cross-Traffic Braking: Saves bumpers in crowded parking lots (standard on Palisade)
- Camera Washers: Midwest winters dirty lenses fast (available on Grand Cherokee)
- Driver Attention Monitors: Beeps if you glance at your phone (Honda/Acura systems work best)
Fuel Economy Secrets Manufacturers Hide
EPA numbers assume gentle acceleration. Reality? Add passengers and AC:
| Model | EPA Combined | Real-World Highway | City (Stop-and-Go Traffic) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hybrid Toyota Highlander | 36 mpg | 34 mpg | 32 mpg |
| Ford Explorer (2.3L EcoBoost) | 23 mpg | 25 mpg | 18 mpg |
| Subaru Ascent | 22 mpg | 24 mpg | 19 mpg |
Shocker: The non-hybrid Honda Pilot often beats hybrids in highway driving thanks to its 10-speed transmission. Always test drive with your typical passenger load.
Pro Tip: Turbocharged engines (like Explorer’s EcoBoost) lose more efficiency in traffic than naturally aspirated ones. If you’re 80% city driving, reconsider turbos.
The Family Factor: Car Seats, Crumbs, and Chaos
As a dad who’s installed 27 car seats (I counted), here’s what matters:
- Door Opening Angle: Honda Pilot’s 75-degree doors > Grand Cherokee’s 68 degrees (prevents head bumps)
- Stain-Resistant Fabric: Hyundai Palisade’s YES Essentials fabric repels blueberry smoothies
- Rear AC Controls: Essential for 3rd-row passengers (missing in base Ford Explorers)
Biggest regret from my cousin’s experience? Buying a model with black leather seats. Midwest summers turn them into frying pans. Go for ventilated seats or light interiors.
Tech That Actually Helps vs. Gimmicks
After using 8 different infotainment systems:
Worth Every Penny
- Wireless Android Auto/CarPlay: Avoids tangled cables (standard on 2024 Palisade/Pilot)
- Digital Rearview Mirror: See past headrests and cargo (game-changer for Explorers)
- Rear Seat Reminders: Beeps if you open back doors before driving (Hyundai/Kia lead here)
Skip These Upgrades
- Gesture Controls: Accidentally changes radio station when you point
- Amazon Alexa Integration: Slower than your phone’s voice assistant
- Rear Seat Entertainment: Tablets with mounts cost 80% less
Most Common What is the Best Midsize SUV Questions (Answered)
Are midsize SUVs better than minivans for families?
Only if you need AWD or higher ground clearance. Minivans like the Honda Odyssey have 40% easier third-row access and 25% more cargo space. But if you ski or deal with snow, SUVs win.
How long do midsize SUVs typically last?
Toyota Highlanders/Honda Pilots regularly hit 200k+ miles with basic maintenance. Korean models (Hyundai/Kia) now average 150k-180k miles. Avoid European luxury brands if keeping beyond 100k miles – repair costs skyrocket.
Should I buy new or used given high prices?
Right now, 1-2 year old models with under 20k miles often cost more than new due to low inventory. Exception: Lease returns from 2021-22 when production was stable.
What’s the most reliable midsize SUV?
Consumer Reports ranks the 2024 Subaru Ascent and Toyota Highlander hybrid as top for predicted reliability. The Jeep Grand Cherokee and VW Atlas sit at the bottom.
Can midsize SUVs tow a camper?
Ford Explorer (5,300 lbs) and Jeep Grand Cherokee (up to 7,200 lbs with V8) can handle small travel trailers. Avoid CVT-equipped models like Subaru Ascent for heavy towing – transmissions overheat.
The Verdict: How to Pick YOUR Best Midsize SUV
So what is the best midsize SUV overall? After 400+ hours of research, I’d say:
- Budget Pick: Hyundai Palisade SEL ($41,200) – premium features at mainstream pricing
- Luxury Experience: Mazda CX-90 Turbo S ($52,000) – near-BMW quality without German maintenance
- Off-Road Ready: Jeep Grand Cherokee Trailhawk ($56,000) – rock-crawling prowess
- Fuel Sipper: Toyota Highlander Hybrid ($42,300) – 35 mpg in mixed driving
But your perfect match depends on three questions: 1) What’s your max monthly payment? 2) How many car seats/dogs will ride weekly? 3) Do you drive more highway or city miles? Nail those, and you’ll find what truly is the best midsize SUV for you.
Final thought: Test drive your top choice during rush hour. A quiet cabin at 35 mph matters more than horsepower you’ll never use. Happy hunting!
Leave a Comments