You know that moment when you make perfect mashed potatoes – creamy, buttery, lump-free clouds of heaven – and then panic hits? Yeah, me too. Last Thanksgiving, I spent hours on my Yukon Gold mash only to realize I forgot to plan anything else. We ended up eating them with scrambled eggs. Not my finest culinary hour.
That disaster got me obsessed with finding what goes with mashed potatoes beyond the usual suspects. After testing 50+ pairings (my family were very willing guinea pigs), here’s the real-deal guide covering classics, curveballs, and everything between.
The Heavy Hitters: Main Dishes That Shine with Mash
Let’s cut to the chase. When most folks ask "what goes with mashed potatoes," they mean mains. Some are obvious crowd-pleasers, others are underrated gems.
Meat Lovers' Corner
Beef and potatoes are BFFs. But not all cuts work equally well:
| Main Dish | Why It Works | Prep Time | Pro Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Meatloaf | The gravy soaks into the mash beautifully | 1 hr 15 min | Add mushrooms to your gravy |
| Slow-Cooked Short Ribs | Fall-apart texture contrasts creamy potatoes | 3.5 hrs | Use red wine in braising liquid |
| Pan-Seared Pork Chops | Caramelized crust adds crunch | 25 min | Brined chops stay juicier |
| Roast Chicken | Classic comfort combo | 1 hr 30 min | Stuff herbs under chicken skin |
| Bangers & Mash | British pub staple for a reason | 40 min | Get quality sausages from butcher |
Personal rant: I used to hate meatloaf until I tried it with super-garlicky mash. The potatoes cut through the denseness – game changer. Still not a fan of dry meatloaf though.
Poultry & Fish Options
Chicken’s obvious, but turkey meatballs? Oh yeah. Even fish works if you’re smart:
- Crispy Skin Salmon: Fatty fish stands up to rich potatoes. Cook skin-side down 90% of the time
- Buttermilk Fried Chicken: Contrasts textures (crunchy vs creamy)
- Turkey-Spinach Meatballs: Lighter than beef but still hearty
My cousin served mashed potatoes with blackened cod once. Sounded weird, tasted incredible. The smoky spice played off the butteriness.
Vegetarian & Vegan Pairings That Don't Suck
Why should carnivores have all the fun? Plant-based mains can rock with mash too.
Mushrooms are MVP here. Portobello "steaks" grilled with balsamic glaze? Heaven. Lentil loaf with mashed sweet potatoes mixed into regular mash? Even better.
My vegan buddy Dave makes killer walnut-mushroom burgers. Slap one on mashed potatoes instead of a bun – messy but mind-blowing.
Vegan Gravy Matters
Bad gravy ruins everything. After 7 failed batches, here’s my foolproof formula:
- Sauté minced mushrooms + shallots in olive oil
- Whisk in 2 tbsp flour until pasty
- Slowly add 2 cups vegetable broth + 1 tbsp soy sauce
- Simmer until thick (add cornstarch slurry if needed)
Way better than store-bought gloop. Trust me.
Sidekicks: Veggies & Salads That Hold Their Own
Got a main but need supporting acts? These sides balance heavy mash.
| Side Dish | Flavor Profile | Prep Effort | Best With |
|---|---|---|---|
| Garlic Sautéed Green Beans | Bright, acidic | Easy (15 min) | Rich meats like pot roast |
| Roasted Brussels Sprouts | Nutty, caramelized | Medium (30 min) | Pork or chicken |
| Tangy Coleslaw | Crisp, vinegary | Easy (10 min) | Fried dishes |
| Maple Glazed Carrots | Sweet, buttery | Easy (20 min) | Turkey or meatloaf |
| Simple Arugula Salad | Peppery, light | Super easy (5 min) | Heavy cream-based mash |
Important note: Avoid other starchy sides like pasta or rice. Double carbs = nap time.
Gravy & Sauces: The Make-or-Break Factor
Great gravy elevates mashed potatoes from good to "can I swim in this?" levels. Here’s the breakdown:
Turkey Gravy
The Thanksgiving classic. Use pan drippings + broth + flour slurry. Secret weapon? A splash of soy sauce for umami depth.
Mushroom Gravy
Earthier than meat gravy. Sauté creminis until crispy, deglaze with sherry. Vegetarian gold.
Unconventional Sauces
Got leftovers? Try these curveballs:
- Korean Gochujang Glaze: Spicy-sweet kick (mix 1:1 with honey)
- Truffle Oil Drizzle: Fancy upgrade (use sparingly!)
- Caramelized Onion Jam: Sweet-savory bomb
My experiment with salsa verde was... controversial. Tasted fresh but weird with mash. Stick to creamy sauces.
Breakfast Mash-Ups You Haven't Tried
Who says mashed potatoes are just for dinner? Leftover mash is breakfast gold.
Pro tip: Make extra mash on purpose. Morning you will thank night-before you.
Top 3 Breakfast Uses:
- Mash Pancakes: Mix 1 cup mash + 1 egg + 2 tbsp flour. Pan-fry in butter.
- Breakfast Bowl: Top reheated mash with fried egg, bacon, chives.
- Potato Waffles: Add extra egg to mash, cook in waffle iron until crispy.
My kids call these "special pancakes." Parenting win.
Global Twists on Mashed Potato Pairings
Think beyond meat-and-three. Worldwide flavors love mashed potatoes too.
British/Irish Style
- Cottage pie (beef base)
- Bangers & mash with onion gravy
Scandinavian Comfort
- Swedish meatballs + lingonberry sauce
- Served with pickled cucumber salad
Japanese Fusion
- Mash with miso-butter swirl
- Topped with crispy nori strips
Tried curry mashed potatoes last winter – added madras curry powder and peas. Felt wrong but tasted so right.
What to Drink with Mashed Potato Dishes
Pairing drinks matters! Creamy textures need specific partners.
| Food Pairing | Best Drink Matches | Why It Works |
|---|---|---|
| Heavy meats + mash | Malbec, Stout beer | Tannins cut through fat |
| Lighter veggie mash | Sauvignon Blanc, Pilsner | Acidity refreshes palate |
| Spicy mash dishes | Riesling, Hard cider | Sweetness balances heat |
Don’t sleep on apple cider with pork chops and mash. Life-altering combo.
Top Mistakes When Pairing with Mashed Potatoes
Seen too many pairing fails. Avoid these:
- Overloading textures: Creamy mash + creamed spinach = mushy mess
- Ignoring acidity: Rich potatoes need bright sides (leony greens!)
- Serving cold mash: Criminal offense. Warm bowls matter
Worst offender? My aunt’s infamous "mashed potato buffet" with 12 heavy sides. We all needed wheelbarrows.
Your Burning Questions Answered
Can mashed potatoes be served with fish?
Absolutely! Pair with fatty fish like salmon or cod. Avoid delicate fish like sole – gets overwhelmed.
What vegetable goes best with mashed potatoes?
Green beans or roasted Brussels sprouts win for texture contrast. Avoid mushy zucchini.
Are mashed potatoes healthy?
Depends. Basic mash (potatoes + milk) is decent. Loaded with butter/cream? Treat yo’self meal. For healthier swaps: use Greek yogurt instead of cream.
Can I make mashed potatoes ahead?
Yes – but reheat with extra milk/butter stirred in. They dry out in the fridge. Make up to 2 days ahead max.
What protein goes with mashed potatoes for vegetarians?
Lentil shepherd’s pie, mushroom stroganoff, or crispy tofu with gravy. All slam dunks.
Why do my mashed potatoes taste gluey?
Overworked potatoes release too much starch. Mash gently – don’t use food processors! Russet potatoes work best.
Sweet potatoes vs regular potatoes – which is better?
Regular for classic pairings. Sweet potatoes rock with spicy/Asian flavors. Mix them half-and-half for best of both worlds.
Final Thoughts: Experiment Fearlessly
After all my testing, here’s the truth: what goes with mashed potatoes is limited only by your guts (and stomach capacity). The classics are classics for good reason – you can’t beat roast chicken swimming in gravy-slicked mash. But that Korean gochujang mash? Don’t knock it till you try it.
Last pro tip: Always make extra gravy. Always. Because when you nail the pairing, you’ll want seconds. And possibly thirds.
Now go forth and mash responsibly.
Leave a Comments