So you want to learn how to make Chicago style pizza? Let me tell you, it's not like tossing a regular pie. We're talking about a buttery crust that cradles mountains of cheese and chunky tomato sauce. My first attempt? Total disaster – ended up with soggy crust and sauce explosions. But after testing 47 batches (yes, I counted), I cracked the code. This guide spills everything: equipment shortcuts, cheese blend secrets, and why your oven's lying about its temperature.
What Makes Chicago Deep Dish Unique?
Picture this: a flaky, almost pastry-like crust rising two inches up the pan. Not bread-like – but buttery and crisp. Then cheese directly on the dough (unlike any other pizza), followed by toppings, and finally a chunky tomato sauce blanket. It's a pizza pie, literally. Many confuse it with Detroit or Sicilian styles, but Chicago deep dish stands apart. The crust texture? Closer to pie dough than bread. Sauce placement? On top! That's crucial for structural integrity. When learning how to make Chicago style pizza, this layering is non-negotiable.
I used to think deep dish was just thick pizza. Boy, was I wrong. During my Chicago food tour, pizzeria owner Tony Bianco schooled me: "If your knuckles don't get tomato sauce drips when eating, it's not authentic." Changed my whole approach.
Essential Equipment (No Fancy Gadgets Needed)
Don't own a professional pizza oven? Good – neither do I. Here's what actually works:
| Tool | Minimum Requirement | Pro Upgrade (Optional) | Why It Matters |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pan | 10" cast iron skillet | 3" deep aluminum pizza pan | Retains heat for crispy edges |
| Oven Thermometer | £5 analog type | Digital with alarm | Most ovens run 25°F cold – ruins crust |
| Dough Press | Wine bottle | Heavy rolling pin | Needed for thin, even base |
Hot Tip That cake pan in your cupboard? Too thin. Borrow grandma's cast iron. The heavy metal prevents burnt bottoms – my batch #23 proved that painfully.
Ingredient Dealbreakers
Substitute these and your deep dish becomes Detroit-style impostor:
| Ingredient | Chicago Standard | Common Mistake | Where to Find |
|---|---|---|---|
| Flour | Bread flour (12-14% protein) | All-purpose flour | Supermarkets (look for "strong" flour) |
| Cheese | Low-moisture whole milk mozzarella | Fresh mozzarella | Cheese counters (pre-grated won't melt right) |
| Tomatoes | San Marzano crushed tomatoes | Pasta sauce | Italian markets or canned goods aisle |
Confession: I once used cheddar in desperation. The oil separation looked like a science experiment gone wrong. Stick to whole milk mozzarella – the fat content prevents weeping.
The Foolproof Step-by-Step Process
Crust That Actually Stays Crispy
Most recipes skip the hydration trick. Combine:
- 4 cups bread flour (scooped, not spooned)
- 1.5 cups warm water (110°F – test with wrist)
- 3 tbsp corn oil (not olive oil – wrong flavor)
- 2 tsp fine sea salt (table salt makes crust tough)
Mix until shaggy. Rest 10 minutes – this relaxes gluten. Now knead 7 minutes by hand (stand mixers overdevelop). Chill overnight. Yes, overnight. This isn't optional when learning how to make Chicago style pizza right.
Sauce Secrets from Chicago Pizzerias
Raw sauce is heresy here. Sauté:
- 3 minced garlic cloves in 2 tbsp olive oil (45 seconds)
- Add 28oz crushed San Marzanos with juices
- 1 tsp dried oregano (rub between palms first)
- Pinch of sugar (cuts acidity without sweetness)
Simmer 20 minutes until thickened. Cool completely – hot sauce melts cheese layers. Learned that from Lou Malnati's sous chef during a kitchen tour.
Assembly: The Make-or-Break Moment
This is where I failed 8 times. Order matters:
- Press dough into oiled pan (up the sides!)
- LAYER 1: Sliced mozzarella (not shredded) covering dough completely
- LAYER 2: Toppings (sausage patties > crumbles)
- LAYER 3: Sauce (cold, thick, 1/2" from edge)
- TOP: Grated Parmesan and oregano sprinkle
Why cheese first? Creates moisture barrier. My batch #16 became soup because I put sauce directly on crust.
Baking: Truth About Time and Temp
Recipe saying "425°F for 25 minutes"? Lies. Real deal:
- Place pan on BOTTOM oven rack
- Bake at 425°F for 15 minutes first
- REDUCE to 375°F for 40-45 minutes
- Internal temp should hit 200°F (meat thermometer)
Why the shift? High heat sets crust structure. Lower temp cooks filling without burning. Forget window doneness checks – cheese will still look pale when done.
Why Resting Isn't Optional
Cutting hot Chicago deep dish causes structural collapse (ask my ruined batch #29). Rest 15 minutes minimum. Use this time:
- Run knife around edges to loosen
- Place cutting board over pan
- Flip upside down (crust now top)
- Slide back upright – prevents sogginess
Advanced Troubleshooting
Even pros face these issues:
| Problem | Culprit | Fix for Next Batch |
|---|---|---|
| Soggy bottom crust | Pan not preheated | Heat empty pan 30 mins before baking |
| Cheese leaking out | Overfilled toppings | Keep toppings 1" below rim |
| Raw dough under toppings | Tomato sauce too wet | Strain tomatoes before using |
Ingredient Ratios That Never Fail
After 47 trials, these proportions work every time:
- Dough weight: 650g for 12" pan (±20g)
- Sauce-to-cheese ratio: 1.5 cups sauce : 1 lb cheese
- Fat content: 3 tbsp oil in dough + 2 tbsp in pan
Deviation causes texture issues. My batch #19 with extra cheese took 70 minutes to cook – outer crust was charcoal.
FAQs: What Real People Ask
Chicago Deep Dish Q&A
Can I freeze Chicago deep dish?
Yes – but only after par-baking. Assemble pizza, bake 20 minutes at 375°F, cool completely, wrap in foil. Reheat frozen at 400°F for 25 minutes. Fresh dough freezes raw terribly.
Why is my crust tough?
Over-kneading or wrong flour. Use bread flour and stop mixing when dough just comes together. Gluten development continues while resting.
Can I make Chicago style pizza gluten-free?
It's tricky. Traditional structure relies on gluten. Best alternative: blend 70% gluten-free flour with 30% almond flour. Adds needed fat. Expect denser texture though.
How do I reheat leftovers?
Never microwave! Place slice on preheated skillet over medium-low heat for 8 minutes. Cover with lid to melt cheese. Restores 90% freshness.
Beyond Deep Dish: Chicago's Other Styles
While learning how to make Chicago style pizza usually means deep dish, locals know these:
| Style | Thickness | Crust Character | Topping Order |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stuffed Pizza | 3-3.5 inches | Top and bottom dough layers | Cheese > toppings > sauce > dough lid |
| Tavern Thin | 1/8 inch | Crackery, crispy edges | Sauce > cheese > toppings |
Stuffed pizza requires special pans with removable bottoms. Not beginner-friendly – my first attempt welded itself to the pan. Tavern thin uses unleavened dough, pressed paper-thin. Both deserve their own guides.
Mastering how to make Chicago style pizza requires patience. Your first attempt might weep sauce or have doughy spots. My early batches were tragic. But when you pull that golden-crusted pie from the oven, cheese bubbling under a tomato blanket? Pure magic. Start with quality ingredients, respect the layering, and never trust your oven's thermostat. Now go conquer that deep dish dream.
Leave a Comments