Thinking about packing your bags for a state with no income tax? I almost did that last year when my accountant showed me how much I paid California. Then I dug deeper. Turns out, states without state income tax aren't magic money-saving zones. Some actually cost you more. Let's cut through the hype.
The Real Deal About Zero Income Tax States
Nine states charge zilch for state income tax right now. Sounds perfect for your wallet? Maybe not. Governments need revenue, so they get creative with other taxes. Higher sales taxes. Crazy property taxes. Fees for breathing air (okay, not that bad). When I compared my old Ohio bills to my cousin's Texas expenses, her "tax-free" life had bigger property tax hits than my entire Ohio tax bundle. Makes you wonder.
Full List of Current Tax-Free States
Here's the 2024 lineup of states without state income tax – but keep scrolling for the catch:
| State | Sales Tax Range | Avg. Property Tax % | Hidden Gotchas |
|---|---|---|---|
| Alaska | 0%–7.5% | 0.97% | Extreme living costs, oil-dependent economy |
| Florida | 6% | 0.89% | Hurricane insurance ($2k+/year) |
| Nevada | 6.85% | 0.60% | Tourist-area price surges (Las Vegas Strip) |
| New Hampshire | 0% | 1.89% | 5% tax on interest/dividends |
| South Dakota | 4.5% | 1.22% | Limited job diversification |
| Tennessee | 7% | 0.71% | Highest sales tax in US for groceries |
| Texas | 6.25% | 1.81% | No-income-tax myth: Top 5 property taxes nationwide |
| Washington | 6.5% | 0.94% | $1+/gallon gas tax |
| Wyoming | 4% | 0.61% | Boom/bust energy cycles |
See Texas' property tax? My friend in Austin pays $12,000 yearly for a 3-bedroom house.
Meanwhile her California friend pays $5,000 for similar value.
But the California friend also pays state income tax.
So who wins?
Texas vs California: Real Numbers
| Scenario | Houston, TX | San Diego, CA |
| Home Value | $450,000 | $850,000 |
| Property Tax | $8,100 (1.8%) | $5,950 (0.7%) |
| State Income Tax (for $120k salary) | $0 | $5,700 |
| Total Tax Burden | $8,100 | $11,650 |
Texas still wins? Not so fast.
Add Texas' higher insurance rates (+$800/year).
Higher utility costs (+$500).
Suddenly the gap narrows to about $2k difference.
Now factor in California's beaches and mountains.
Is $2k/year worth that trade-off? Depends.
Who Actually Saves Money?
Based on my research and talking to tax pros, these folks benefit most from states without state income tax:
- Remote workers earning NYC/SF salaries while living in Tampa
- Retirees with fixed incomes (Taxation of Social Security varies)
- Real estate investors using depreciation strategies
- Business owners who can deduct SALT limitations
Warning: Tennessee taxes investment income over $1,250! Found that out when my stocks paid dividends.
Hidden Costs You Can't Ignore
Florida's Insurance Nightmare
My aunt's home insurance tripled to $6,000 after Hurricane Ian. Many insurers fled the state. No state income tax? Great. But check insurance calculators before moving.
Washington's Gas Prices
Filled up near Seattle last month. Nearly $5/gallon. Their gas tax is America's second highest. That commute adds up fast.
Tourist Trap Pricing
Try buying groceries near the Las Vegas Strip. Milk costs 40% more than in suburbs. Live near attractions? Your wallet feels it daily.
Key Questions People Forget to Ask
Do I need to live there full-time?
Most states require 183+ days. Florida audits newcomers aggressively. Keep flight receipts!
What if I work remotely for another state?
Complex! Some states (like NY) still tax you if your employer's based there. Talk to a CPA.
Are there city taxes?
Watch out! Tennessee has no state income tax but Memphis charges earnings tax. Always check local rules.
How do schools get funded?
Hint: Through your property taxes. Texas spends heavily on schools hence high rates. Quality varies wildly.
My Personal Experience in Tennessee
Moved to Nashville for 18 months. Zero state income tax felt amazing on payday. Until:
- 9.25% sales tax on everything (even groceries!)
- $200/month "natural gas fee" in winter
- Rising rents from music industry growth
Ended up moving back to Colorado. The mountains won.
Bottom Line: Should You Move?
If you're high-income and hate tax paperwork? States without state income tax simplify life. But run real calculations:
- Get quotes for property tax on comparable homes
- Check insurance rates (car/home)
- Calculate gas prices for your commute
- Tour grocery stores there (seriously)
Sometimes paying moderate state income tax beats the alternatives. Sometimes not. Just know the whole picture before chasing that "tax-free" dream.
Still tempted?
Try renting for a year first.
Your future self might thank you.
Leave a Comments