So you're thinking about buying a house. Congrats! But then that nagging question hits: what percentage of your income should your mortgage be? I remember sweating over this exact thing when I bought my first place. My realtor threw out "28%!" like it was gospel. Turns out? That would've drowned me.
Here's the raw truth banks won't tell you: that magic number depends entirely on YOUR life. Your debts. Your job security. Even your hobbies. Let's cut through the noise and find what works for you.
The 28/36 Rule: That Old Chestnut
You've probably heard this golden rule: spend no more than 28% of your gross monthly income on housing, and no more than 36% on total debt payments. It's everywhere. Lenders love it. Why? Because it's simple math for them.
Example: The 28/36 Rule in Action
Say you earn $5,000/month gross.
- Max mortgage payment: $5,000 x 0.28 = $1,400/month
- Max total debt (mortgage + car + student loans): $5,000 x 0.36 = $1,800/month
Sounds neat, right? But here's why I'm not a fan:
- Ignores taxes: Gross ≠ take-home pay. That $5,000 might be $3,800 after taxes.
- Forgets hidden costs: Insurance? Property tax? HOA fees? They add hundreds.
- Life happens: Got kids? Medical bills? Good luck squeezing those in.
I followed this rule in 2018. Big mistake. My "affordable" mortgage left me eating ramen when my car died. So let's talk real-world numbers.
What Actually Works? Breaking Down the Percentages
Forget textbook answers. Look at your net income (what hits your bank account). That's your real budget fuel. Here's how different slices feel:
| Mortgage as % of Net Income | What It Feels Like | Who It Might Fit | Danger Zone |
|---|---|---|---|
| < 25% | Breathing room. Vacations? Savings? Doable. | Dual incomes, no debt, frugal lifestyles | Low risk |
| 25% - 30% | Comfortable. Occasional treats, steady savings. | Most stable jobs, moderate debt | Manageable |
| 30% - 35% | Tight. Budgeting required. Little wiggle room. | High earners with discipline, low other debts | Caution needed |
| 35% - 40% | Stressful. Emergencies hurt. Savings stall. | Rare cases (e.g., guaranteed raises) | High risk |
| > 40% | House poor. Anxiety central. No margin for error. | Almost no one sustainably | Danger! |
I learned this hard way. At 33% of net? I canceled Netflix and stopped seeing friends for coffee. Not worth the granite countertops.
Key Takeaway:
Aim for 25-30% of your NET income for maximum sanity. Anything over 35%? You'll feel it every single month when bills roll in.
The Hidden Costs That Wreck Budgets (Don't Skip This!)
When lenders say "mortgage payment," they rarely mean just your loan. Missing these extras is why people overshoot their ideal percentage of income for mortgage payments.
- Property Taxes: Vary wildly. A $300k home might cost $200/month in Alabama or $800/month in New Jersey.
- Home Insurance: Flood zones? Hurricane risk? Adds up fast. Mine jumped 30% last year.
- PMI (Private Mortgage Insurance): If you put down <20%, add 0.5% - 1.5% of loan value/year. On $300k? That's $125-$375/month!
- HOA/Condo Fees: Could be $50 or $500. Ask BEFORE buying.
- Maintenance & Repairs: Rule of thumb? Budget 1-3% of home value/year. For a $400k house? $4,000-$12,000/year. Ouch.
Watch Out:
That "perfect" house at 28% gross could easily hit 40%+ of net when you add taxes, insurance, and HOA fees. Calculate everything.
Your Personal Mortgage Percentage Calculator
Ready to crunch your numbers? Grab pay stubs, bills, and bank statements. Let's do this step-by-step.
Step 1: Calculate Your True Net Income
Gross income is meaningless. Use take-home pay AFTER:
- Taxes (federal/state/local)
- Retirement contributions (401k, IRA)
- Health insurance premiums
Example: Sarah earns $72,000/year gross ($6,000/month). After deductions? $4,300/month net.
Step 2: Tally All Existing Monthly Debts
Lenders look at debt-to-income ratio (DTI). So should you. Include:
- Car payments
- Student loans
- Credit card minimums
- Personal loans
- Child support/alimony
Sarah's Debts: Car loan ($300) + Student loans ($200) = $500/month
Step 3: Estimate Total Housing Costs
Don't just look at mortgage principal and interest. Include:
| Cost Type | How to Estimate | Sarah's Estimate |
|---|---|---|
| Mortgage (P&I) | Use online calculator with current rates | $1,250 |
| Property Tax | Check county records or realtor.com | $350 |
| Home Insurance | Get quotes (try Policygenius) | $120 |
| PMI | 0.8% of loan if down payment <20% | $90 |
| HOA Fees | Ask seller or HOA directly | $100 |
| TOTAL | $1,910/month |
Step 4: Run the Numbers
- Housing Cost % of Net: $1,910 ÷ $4,300 = 44.4% → WAY too high!
- Total DTI: (Housing $1,910 + Debts $500) ÷ Gross $6,000 = 40.2% → Barely passes lender max!
Smart Move:
Sarah needs to either increase down payment (to kill PMI), find cheaper homes, or pay off debts first. At 44% of net? Emergency savings vanish fast.
When Breaking the Rules Might Work (Rarely!)
Sometimes a higher mortgage percentage of income makes sense. But tread carefully.
Case 1: The High Earner
If you net $15,000/month after tax? Spending $5,250 (35%) leaves $9,750 for everything else. That's livable.
Case 2: Short-Term Sacrifice
Taking 38% for 2 years because:
- Your spouse returns to work soon
- You expect a big promotion
- Rent would cost even more (like SF or NYC)
Warning: Promises aren't paychecks. Banks qualified ARM-buyers in 2007 too. We know how that ended.
Case 3: Low Debt Lifestyle
No car payment? Student loans paid off? Using 33% on housing might feel like 28% to others.
Red Flags You're Overextending
How do you know if your mortgage percentage is too high? Your life tells you:
- You rely on credit cards for basic groceries
- Retirement savings dropped to zero
- One medical bill would cause overdraft
- You avoid looking at bank balances
- "Side hustle" searches spike on your browser
Been there. My furnace died six months in. At 34% of net? I maxed a credit card. Took 2 years to dig out.
What If You're Already House Poor?
Don't panic. Options exist:
- Refinance: Lower rate = lower payment. But watch closing costs!
- Rent a Room: Airbnb or long-term tenant adds income.
- Downsize: Sell and buy cheaper. Painful but freeing.
- Debt Avalanche: Crush high-interest debts first to free cash flow.
Real Talk:
Selling saved me after 18 months of stress. My "dream home" became a nightmare at 37% of net income. Now at 26%? I sleep better.
Mortgage Percentage FAQs (Real Questions I Get)
Is the 28% rule based on gross or net income?
Gross. Which is why it's flawed. Lenders use gross for DTI ratios (debt-to-income). But you should budget based on net. What actually hits your bank account matters.
What percentage of income should your mortgage be if you have high student loans?
Lower! Say you pay $800/month for loans. Aim for 22-27% of net for housing max. Otherwise, you'll be squeezed. Debt stacks fast.
Should I include bonuses/commissions in my income calculation?
Only if they're guaranteed. Base your mortgage percentage on stable income. Bonuses fund vacations or repairs – not baseline payments.
How does home equity affect what percentage of income my mortgage should be later?
Good news! As you pay down principal, your payment stays steady while your income (hopefully) grows. So percentage drops over time. Focus on surviving the early years.
Do lenders really care about the mortgage percentage of income guidelines?
Yes – they won't approve loans exceeding ~43-50% DTI usually. But their max is NOT your safe zone. They care if you default. You care about living well.
Beyond Percentages: Your Lifestyle Audit
Numbers don't tell the whole story. Before signing:
- Track spending for 3 months: Use Mint or YNAB. See where cash really goes.
- Play "disaster scenarios": What if rates rise? Job loss? Major repair?
- Visit at different times: That charming street? Friday night might reveal party central.
- Talk to neighbors: Ask about utility costs, tax hikes, or special assessments.
I skipped this last step. My "quiet" street had 3 AM garbage trucks. Research matters.
Final Reality Check:
The right percentage of income for your mortgage lets you live – not just exist. If house viewing leaves you anxious about payments? Listen to that instinct. Cheaper doors open happier futures.
Leave a Comments