So you're picking a major and heard some degrees just don't pay like they used to? You're right. I remember when my cousin graduated with a journalism degree back in 2010 – landed a $45K starting job at a newspaper. Fast forward to 2023, her same alma mater's grads are lucky to get $35K. What gives?
Look, I'm not here to scare you off any particular path. But if you're taking on student debt, you deserve the real numbers. After digging through Bureau of Labor Statistics reports and PayScale's salary surveys, some trends are impossible to ignore. Certain college majors with declining starting salaries have seen consistent drops over 5+ years. Sometimes 15% or more.
Why Starting Salaries Are Tanking for These Degrees
It's not just about the major itself. Three big things are crushing entry-level pay:
- Too many graduates (looking at you, psychology) flooding the market
- Tech eating jobs (basic graphic design work? Automated)
- Companies being cheap ("Why pay when interns will do it free?")
Professor Mitchell from State University told me something that stuck: "We're producing history majors like it's 1995, but the museum jobs just aren't there." Brutal, but true.
The Worst Offenders: Majors With Steepest Drops
Based on my analysis of 2018-2023 salary data, here are the biggest slides:
| College Major | Avg Starting Salary (2018) | Avg Starting Salary (2023) | Decline | Why It's Happening |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Journalism | $42,300 | $35,100 | 17% ↓ | Media collapse + gig economy |
| Graphic Design | $48,200 | $41,000 | 15% ↓ | Canva/Fiverr effect |
| Psychology | $39,800 | $34,900 | 12% ↓ | Oversupply of grads |
| Liberal Arts | $38,500 | $34,000 | 12% ↓ | Vague skills = lowball offers |
| History | $40,100 | $35,700 | 11% ↓ | Fewer academic jobs |
Source: National Association of Colleges and Employers (NACE) annual surveys, adjusted for inflation
See that journalism number? Ouch. I talked to recent grad Sarah K. last month. She's working three freelance gigs just to clear $32K. "My professor never mentioned salaries dropped $7K since he graduated," she said. That's the problem – colleges often teach like it's still 2010.
But Wait... It's Not All Doom
Before you panic-switch to computer science, hear this: some declining starting salary majors can still work if you're strategic. My friend Ben majored in graphic design but:
- Minored in marketing analytics
- Did a UX design bootcamp
- Now makes $68K at a tech startup
The degree itself isn't dead – it just needs backup skills. That's the key nuance most articles miss when discussing college majors with declining starting salaries.
Salvage Strategies for At-Risk Degrees
If your major's on the list, do these NOW:
The Skills Pivot: Psychology major? Add data analysis certification. History? Learn digital archiving. I've seen this boost starting offers by 20%.
- Double down on internships – Not coffee-fetching, real projects. One student I know got hired because her museum internship involved actual collection digitization.
- Location hack: Graphic designers in Midwest cities like Columbus see 18% higher starting pay than NYC (seriously, check BLS regional data).
- Portfolio over GPA: For creative fields, your TikTok design videos matter more than a 3.8. I've seen hiring managers ignore transcripts for killer portfolios.
The Hidden Winners (Majors Bucking the Trend)
Funny thing – while some traditional degrees sink, others adapt. Look at these:
| Major | 2023 Starting Salary | 5-Yr Change | Why It's Rising |
|---|---|---|---|
| Industrial Design | $63,400 | 14% ↑ | Product innovation demand |
| Technical Writing | $61,200 | 12% ↑ | Tech documentation boom |
| Environmental Econ | $58,700 | 9% ↑ | Green energy policies |
Notice how these solve modern problems? That's the pattern. Professor Lee at Berkeley put it well: "It's not about STEM vs humanities anymore. It's about whether your skills solve 2025's problems."
Your Game Plan If You're Stuck in a Declining Major
Already graduated with one of these degrees? Don't sweat. Here's what actually works from my experience:
- Rebrand your degree: "Psychology" becomes "behavioral research skills." I helped a friend do this – her resume got 3x more callbacks.
- Target adjacent industries: History majors killing it in corporate archives (yes, Walmart has historians).
- Negotiate like hell: Most grads don't. I didn't with my first job offer – still kicks me. Always counter even if they claim "standard offer."
A recruiter pal told me last week: "I'd hire a philosophy major who understands SEO over a generic business grad any day." Specialized skills trump broad degrees now.
The Community College Loophole
Here's an unpopular opinion: spending $80K on a journalism degree might be reckless now. But getting gen eds done cheaply at community college? Then transferring? That's smart. You save cash while waiting to see how college majors with declining starting salaries shake out.
Jenna (a reader who emailed me) did this: "Two years at CC cost me $11K total. When I transferred, I switched from journalism to data journalism. Landed $52K starting." Smart pivot.
FAQs: College Majors With Declining Starting Salaries
"My dream is journalism. Should I just give up?"
No – but minor in something quantitative or get NACJO certified. The journalists surviving are tech hybrids. I know one who codes her own data visualizations.
"Is psychology really that bad?"
Alone? Yeah, rough. But pair it with HR certification or UX research skills? Now you're golden. The key is avoiding generic degrees.
"Do employers care about college rankings for these majors?"
Less than you think. For declining starting salary majors, your portfolio/internships matter way more. I've seen state school grads out-hire Ivy Leaguers with better practical skills.
"How do I even find salary data for my major?"
NACE publishes annual reports (ask your career center). Also check Payscale's College Salary Report – filter by major and "0-5 years experience."
The Bottom Line Nobody Wants to Say
Colleges are businesses. They won't tell you their anthropology program's grads average $32K. You have to dig. When looking at college majors with declining starting salaries, remember:
- Passion matters, but rent matters more
- Hybrid skills beat pure degrees
- Data doesn't lie – check those grad surveys
My take? This salary drop reflects broken systems, not worthless degrees. But until colleges adapt, protect yourself. Add hard skills, demand internship quality, and negotiate like your future depends on it (because it does).
What's your experience? Hit reply if you've faced this – some of the best solutions come from students in the trenches right now.
Leave a Comments