That Thing You Do! Movie Guide: Cast, Soundtrack & Legacy Explained

Okay, let's talk about that thing you do movie. You know the one. It pops into your head sometimes. Maybe you hummed the title song in the shower this morning. Or you caught a glimpse of a vintage Vox teardrop guitar. Or perhaps you saw Tom Everett Scott in something else and thought, "Hey, it's Guy Patterson!" For a movie nearly 30 years old (yikes, time flies!), That Thing You Do! has this uncanny knack for sticking around in the collective pop culture memory. It's not just a movie; it feels like revisiting a sunny, simpler time, even if you weren't alive in 1964 Erie, Pennsylvania. I remember stumbling upon it late one night on cable back in the late 90s and being instantly charmed, then annoyed I'd missed the start. Went out and rented it the next day.

What Exactly IS "That Thing You Do!"?

If you're scratching your head thinking, "Wait, which movie is this again?", let's clear that up. Released in 1996, That Thing You Do! was the writing and directing debut of Tom Hanks. Yeah, *that* Tom Hanks. It’s his love letter to the fleeting fame of 1960s American garage bands experiencing that whirlwind moment of pop success. The core story follows The Wonders (originally The Oneders... pronounced "The O-need-ers", leading to constant confusion – a running gag I always found painfully realistic for small-town bands trying too hard).

Their journey starts in Erie, PA. Jimmy Mattingly (Johnathon Schaech) is the intense songwriter. Lenny Haise (Steve Zahn) is the goofball guitarist. T.B. Player (Ethan Embry) is the quiet bassist. Guy Patterson (Tom Everett Scott) is the jazz-loving drummer reluctantly pulled in as a last-minute substitute. And Faye Dolan (Liv Tyler) is Jimmy's girlfriend, their unofficial manager, and the heart of the group. They record Jimmy's ballad, "That Thing You Do!", but it's Guy's spontaneous decision to crank up the tempo during a gig that transforms it into an infectious, foot-stomping hit. Suddenly, they're signed to Play-Tone records by the slick Mr. White (Tom Hanks), thrust onto tour, appearing on TV, and rocketing up the charts. It's pure, undiluted, joyful ascent... followed by the inevitable complexities and pressures of sudden fame. The charm is in the details – the period-perfect production design, the killer costumes (Faye's outfits!), the spot-on music, and the genuine chemistry among the young cast.

It captures that specific, almost magical period in the mid-60s *before* things got heavy with Vietnam and the counterculture explosion. It was all about catchy tunes, matching suits, and appearing on Hollywood TV shows. The movie nails that energy perfectly. Though honestly, Jimmy's pretentiousness grates on me more with every rewatch. Guy and Faye were clearly the soul of that band.

Why You Really Oughta Watch It (Or Rewatch It)

Look, if you haven't seen that thing you do movie, you're missing out on something genuinely special. It's not some gritty rock biopic. It's not cynical. It's warm, funny, heartfelt, and incredibly rewatchable. Here's the deal:

  • The Music is Legitimately Fantastic: This isn't just movie soundtrack filler. The title track, written by Adam Schlesinger (Fountains of Wayne), is an absolute banger. It *sounds* like a lost gem from 1964. It charted *for real* in 1996! The rest of the Play-Tone catalogue, from Diane Dane to the fictional bands, is meticulously crafted to evoke the era. You'll be humming them for days. "All My Only Dreams" is surprisingly lovely, even if Jimmy thinks it's disposable pop.
  • A Stellar Young Cast Bursting With Charm: Tom Everett Scott is perfect as the jazz-loving drummer finding his voice. Liv Tyler radiates warmth and quiet strength as Faye. Steve Zahn steals practically every scene he's in as Lenny – his infectious energy is a huge part of the movie's appeal. Johnathon Schaech captures the tortured artist ego effectively (almost too effectively sometimes). Ethan Embry is sweetly understated. They *feel* like a real band navigating weird fame.
  • Tom Hanks Behind the Camera (And In Front): Hanks' direction is confident and affectionate. He clearly loves this world and these characters. His performance as the driven, slightly mysterious Mr. White is a delightful supporting turn. You sense his passion project energy throughout.
  • A Pure Dose of Feel-Good Nostalgia: Even if you weren't around in the 60s, the movie creates such a specific, inviting atmosphere. It's optimistic, funny, and ultimately satisfying. It’s comfort food in cinematic form. Perfect for a lazy Sunday afternoon when you need a pick-me-up. Though the ending still feels a tiny bit rushed to me – I wanted just a *few* more minutes with Guy and Faye.
  • Surprisingly Sharp Observations: Beneath the sunshine, it subtly explores the fleeting nature of fame ("One hit wonders? Most groups *are* one hit wonders!"), artistic compromise, and the bonds of friendship strained by sudden success. It’s deeper than it first appears.

So yeah, the That Thing You Do movie experience is pretty unique. It’s like finding a perfect pop single from decades ago – instantly catchy, leaving you smiling.

Getting Your Hands on "That Thing You Do!": Where to Watch and Own It

Alright, practical stuff. You're convinced (hopefully). How do you actually watch That Thing You Do!? Streaming rights shift like sand, and physical media options vary. Here’s the breakdown as of late 2023 (but seriously, always double-check – it moves around!):

Platform/Format Availability Notes & Cost
Streaming (Subscription) Disney+ (in many regions) Often included with your sub. Easiest option currently.
Streaming (Rental/Purchase) Amazon Prime Video, Apple TV, Google Play, Vudu, YouTube Typically $3.99 rental, $14.99 purchase (HD). Prices fluctuate.
DVD Widely Available Original release. Easy to find used ($5-$10) or new ($10-$15). Standard definition.
Blu-ray Available (Check Amazon, eBay) Significantly better picture/sound than DVD. Look for the 2011 release. Usually $15-$25.
Extended Cut Limited Availability An extended version aired on TV once upon a time. Very hard to find officially. Rumored to add ~20 mins, fleshing out Jimmy/Faye backstory. Some bootlegs exist, but buyer beware! Would love a proper official release.

My advice? If you have Disney+, start there. If you love it and want the best quality, hunt down the Blu-ray. The music deserves it. Renting is fine for a first taste. Finding the elusive extended cut feels like searching for a lost Play-Tone single these days. Maybe someday!

The Wonders: Where Are They Now? (The Actors, Not the Band!)

Part of the fun of revisiting That Thing You Do! is seeing this talented cast right at the start of their careers. Let's catch up with the folks who brought The Wonders to life:

Actor Character Career Highlights (Beyond The Wonders)
Tom Everett Scott Guy Patterson (Drummer) Starred in "An American Werewolf in Paris," "Boiler Room," had a long run on "ER," and numerous TV roles ("Southland," "The Good Wife," "13 Reasons Why," "La Brea"). Still acts steadily.
Liv Tyler Faye Dolan Became a major star in "The Lord of the Rings" trilogy (Arwen), "Armageddon," "The Incredible Hulk," "The Leftovers" (HBO), "9-1-1: Lone Star." Also a model.
Steve Zahn Lenny Haise (Guitarist) Beloved character actor. "Rescue Dawn," "Sahara," "Dallas Buyers Club," "The White Lotus" (HBO - Emmy nominated!), "The Righteous Gemstones," countless comedies ("You've Got Mail," "Stuart Little"). Always hilarious.
Johnathon Schaech Jimmy Mattingly (Singer/Songwriter) Appeared in "How to Make an American Quilt," "The Doom Generation," "Prom Night," "Legends of Tomorrow" (DC TV series), and many Hallmark movies. Also a writer/producer.
Ethan Embry T.B. Player (Bassist) Started young! "Empire Records," "Can't Hardly Wait," "Sweet Home Alabama," "Blown Away," "Grace and Frankie," "The Walking Dead: World Beyond." Consistently working actor.
Tom Hanks Mr. White (Plus Director/Writer) Became... well, Tom Hanks. Two-time Oscar winner ("Philadelphia," "Forrest Gump"), countless classics ("Saving Private Ryan," "Cast Away," "Toy Story," "Apollo 13," "Captain Phillips"... the list is endless). Also a producer, writer, and director ("Larry Crowne," "Greyhound").

It's cool to see how they all carved distinct paths. Zahn definitely became the breakout comedy star, while Tyler achieved massive blockbuster fame. Scott remains reliably good in everything he does. Schaech works constantly. Embry is always a solid presence. And Hanks? Yeah, he did alright for himself.

The Soundtrack That Stole Our Hearts (And Charted!)

Let's be real, the music is half the reason the that thing you do movie works so well. Adam Schlesinger (RIP) absolutely nailed the assignment. The title song isn't just good *for a movie song*; it's a genuinely great pop song from any era. It peaked at No. 41 on the Billboard Hot 100 in 1996! That's rare air for a song written specifically for a film set in the 60s.

The soundtrack album is packed with gems. It expertly mixes The Wonders' hits with other fictional Play-Tone artists, creating a believable musical universe. Here's the essential tracklist from the original release:

  • "That Thing You Do!" - The Wonders (The absolute earworm hit)
  • "Lovin' You Lots and Lots" - The Wonders (Their cheesy ballad attempt)
  • "All My Only Dreams" - The Wonders (Much better ballad, Jimmy's earlier style)
  • "Dance With Me Tonight" - The Wonders (Another uptempo banger)
  • "Little Wild One" - The Wonders (Featured in the film)
  • "She Knows It" - The Heardsmen (Play-Tone's other big act)
  • "Hold My Hand, Hold My Heart" - The Chantrellines (Girl group goodness)
  • "Mr. Downtown" - Freddy Fredrickson (Crooner style)
  • "Voyage Around the Moon" - The Saturn 5 (Surf rock instrumental)
  • "Drive Faster" - The G Men (Garage rock)
  • "Time to Blow" - The Wonders (Their jazzier, Guy-influenced sound)

Finding the soundtrack can be a bit of a quest now. The original CD is out of print and often pricey on resale sites. Digital downloads (iTunes, Amazon Music) are usually available for around $9.99. Occasionally, it pops up on streaming services like Spotify or Apple Music, but licensing can be tricky – it comes and goes. I lucked out finding a decent vinyl reissue a few years back, but that was pure chance. Keep those eyes peeled! It’s worth owning.

Fun fact: Mike Viola (The Candy Butchers) provided the lead vocals for Guy Patterson's singing voice on the tracks! Tom Everett Scott lip-synced perfectly. Schlesinger wrote or co-wrote almost all the original songs. The attention to musical detail is incredible.

That Thing You Do! Movie FAQ: Burning Questions Answered

Okay, let's tackle some of the most common things people wonder about after watching That Thing You Do! or before diving in. You know you wanna know:

Is "That Thing You Do!" based on a true story?

No, not directly. It's an original story written by Tom Hanks. However, it's heavily inspired by the real-life explosion of garage rock and the "one-hit wonder" phenomenon in the mid-1960s. Hanks drew from the general energy, aesthetics, and rapid rise (and fall) of bands influenced by The Beatles and the British Invasion. Bands like The Knickerbockers ("Lies") or The Gentrys ("Keep On Dancing") embody that spirit. The Play-Tone label feels reminiscent of labels like Capitol or Colpix.

How old was Liv Tyler during filming?

Liv Tyler was only 18 years old when That Thing You Do! was filmed in 1995. Pretty amazing considering her poised and warm performance as Faye. Johnathon Schaech (Jimmy) was 25, Tom Everett Scott (Guy) was 24, Steve Zahn (Lenny) was 27, and Ethan Embry (T.B.) was 17!

Did the actors really play their instruments?

Mostly, yes! They underwent serious musical boot camp. Tom Everett Scott (Guy) was already a drummer. Steve Zahn (Lenny) learned guitar. Ethan Embry (T.B.) learned bass. Johnathon Schaech (Jimmy) learned basic guitar chords for the performance scenes. The singing was primarily done by professional vocalists (like Mike Viola for Guy). But the fingering, strumming, and drumming you see? That's largely them. The rehearsals were intense, which is why the band scenes feel so authentic. You can tell they put the work in.

What exactly happens at the end?

The band breaks up. After Jimmy impulsively quits during a show (after seeing Faye and Guy connect), the writing is on the wall. Mr. White swiftly replaces Jimmy on vocals for the TV appearance with "Captain Geech and the Shrimp Shack Shooters" (Lenny, T.B., and Guy). It's a chaotic, final hurrah. Guy decides to stay in LA to pursue jazz and film scoring. He and Faye share a meaningful look – a clear promise of a future together. Lenny joins the Marines. T.B. goes back to Erie. Jimmy disappears into his own world. Mr. White hints at future projects with Guy. The final shot is Guy conducting an orchestra, living his dream. It's bittersweet but hopeful, focusing on Guy and Faye finding their path.

Was there ever a sequel?

No. Despite persistent fan rumors and occasional vague comments from Hanks over the years about ideas (like catching up with Guy in the 70s scoring blaxploitation films!), a proper sequel has never materialized. Hanks has said he feels the story was complete. Personally, while I'd love to see Guy and Faye again, I kinda agree. The magic of the film is in capturing that specific, fleeting moment. Sometimes sequels just dilute that. The mystery works.

Where was it filmed?

While set in Erie, Pennsylvania, most filming occurred in Southern California:

  • Erie street scenes were shot in Orange County towns like Orange, Garden Grove, and Costa Mesa.
  • The iconic Hollywood TV show performance was filmed at the Pantages Theatre in Hollywood.
  • Play-Tone Records headquarters was the former Tower Records building on Sunset Boulevard.
  • The restaurant where Guy and Faye have their first real conversation is the now-closed Ships coffee shop in West LA.
  • The airport scene? LAX, naturally.
They did a fantastic job making SoCal feel like chilly Erie!

Beyond the Screen: The Lasting Charm of a One-Hit Wonder Story

Why does that thing you do movie endure? It wasn't a massive blockbuster in 1996. Critics liked it well enough (Roger Ebert gave it 3 stars), but it didn't set the world on fire. Yet, here we are, decades later, still talking about it, still humming that song.

I think it boils down to a few things. First, it’s steeped in genuine affection. Hanks loves this era and these characters, and that love is contagious. Second, it captures a universal fantasy – the sudden rush of creating something that connects with people, the thrill of seeing your wildest dreams come true, even if only briefly. Who hasn't imagined that? Third, it’s executed with incredible craft. The period detail is impeccable without being stuffy. The music is perfect. The performances are pitch-perfect across the board. Zahn’s Lenny alone is a masterclass in scene-stealing without derailing the film.

It also taps into a bittersweet truth: most success stories aren't linear. They're messy, fleeting, and involve compromise. The Wonders' journey feels authentic in its imperfection. They don't become the biggest band in the world. They have one glorious hit, internal tensions flare, and they drift apart. But the film isn't cynical about it. It celebrates the joy of *that thing* they did, that one perfect moment captured on vinyl and film. It reminds us that sometimes the journey, the friendships forged, and the art created in that brief flare of light is what truly matters. Guy finding his true calling in jazz, finding Faye – that's the real happy ending, not the Billboard charts.

So, whether you're discovering That Thing You Do! for the first time or revisiting it like an old favorite record, there’s always something new to appreciate. The infectious energy, the killer tunes, the warmth of the characters, that perfect 60s vibe. It’s a little cinematic miracle that just makes you feel good. Now, if you'll excuse me, I think I need to go listen to that song... again.

Leave a Comments

Recommended Article