Ever wonder why New York City is called the Big Apple? It's one of those nicknames everyone knows but hardly anyone knows the real story behind. I remember asking a cab driver about it once, and he just shrugged saying "Because everything big happens here, man." Well, turns out he was only half-right. The truth involves 1920s horse races, struggling jazz musicians, and a tourism campaign that accidentally saved the name from obscurity.
The Horse Racing Roots (Yes, Really!)
Believe it or not, the term started at the racetrack. Back in the 1920s, New York offered the biggest racing prizes in America. John J. Fitz Gerald, a sports writer for the New York Morning Telegraph, overheard stable hands in New Orleans calling NYC's racetracks "the Big Apple" – meaning the ultimate prize, like the biggest, shiniest apple a horse could win. Fitz Gerald loved the phrase so much he made it the title of his racing column starting in 1924.
Fun fact: Fitz Gerald's first use of "Big Apple" appeared on February 18, 1924: "The Big Apple. The dream of every lad that ever threw a leg over a thoroughbred and the goal of all horsemen. There's only one Big Apple. That's New York."
Key Figures in the Early Days
| Person | Role | Contribution |
|---|---|---|
| John J. Fitz Gerald | Journalist | Popularized term through racing columns (1920s) |
| Walter Winchell | Gossip Columnist | Used term for NYC nightlife in 1920s-30s |
| Robert Emmerich | Songwriter | Wrote hit song "The Big Apple" (1937) |
How Jazz Musicians Saved the Nickname
By the 1930s, "Big Apple" was fading until jazz musicians revived it. For touring performers, NYC was where you proved yourself. As drummer Chick Webb reportedly said: "There are many apples on the tree, but only one Big Apple." New York meant the top venues, the toughest crowds, and the highest-paying gigs.
I once met an elderly sax player in Harlem who told me: "Back then, if your bandleader said 'We're heading to the Apple,' you knew you'd made it. Meant you weren't stuck playing dive bars in Cleveland anymore." That real stakes made the nickname stick in cultural memory.
NYC Jazz Clubs That Kept the Name Alive
- Cotton Club (142nd St & Lenox Ave): Paid musicians 5x more than Chicago clubs
- Minton's Playhouse (210 W 118th St): Birthplace of bebop where Charlie Parker ruled
- Savoy Ballroom (Lenox Ave between 140th-141st St): Called "Big Apple Headquarters" by dancers
The Near-Death and Revival in the 1970s
By the 1950s, the term was fading again – until NYC's 1970s bankruptcy crisis. The tourism board needed to rebrand the crime-ridden city. Marketing whiz Charles Gillett rediscovered Fitz Gerald's columns and launched the "Big Apple Campaign" with red apple logos. Frankly, it was a Hail Mary pass. Even locals thought it was silly at first.
But the campaign exploded. I've seen the original sketches at the NYC archives – those cheerful apple buttons (still sold today) somehow made the gritty city feel approachable. By 1997, the corner of 54th & Broadway where Fitz Gerald lived was officially renamed "Big Apple Corner."
Big Apple Tourist Spots You Can Visit Today
| Location | Address | Why Visit | Hours |
|---|---|---|---|
| Big Apple Corner | W 54th St & Broadway | Historic plaque where Fitz Gerald lived | 24/7 (public sidewalk) |
| NYC Visitor Center | 810 7th Ave | See original 1970s campaign memorabilia | 8:30AM-6PM daily |
| Louis Armstrong House | 34-56 107th St, Queens | Where "Big Apple" was commonly used by jazz greats | 10AM-5PM (Tue-Fri) |
Debunking Common Myths
You'll hear wild theories about why New York City is called the Big Apple. Let's squash the big ones:
- Brothel Theory: No evidence "apple" meant prostitution here. That myth stems from misreading 19th-century French slang.
- Washington Irving Theory: People claim writer Irving used "Big Apple" in 1809. Total fabrication – his writings never mention it.
- Central Park Apple Trees: Cute idea, but the park's first apple trees were planted in 1997 (for the nickname's 100th anniversary).
Honestly, the real story's more interesting than these myths. It wasn't some marketing gimmick – it grew organically from racetracks to jazz clubs to city identity.
Why Does the Nickname Resonate?
So why did "Big Apple" stick when nicknames like "Gotham" faded? Three reasons:
- Symbolism: Apples mean opportunity (think Adam and Eve) and Americana (apple pie).
- Exclusivity: Musicians and jockeys framed it as the pinnacle you had to earn.
- Optimism: During tough times like the Great Depression or 1970s crisis, it represented hope.
Today, it perfectly captures NYC's contradictions. Like an apple, it's shiny but tough. Welcoming but competitive. That's why when people ask why New York City is called the Big Apple, it's more than history – it's the city's DNA.
Your Big Apple Questions Answered
Where did the term "Big Apple" come from?
It originated in 1920s horse racing slang. New York's tracks offered the biggest prizes, so stable hands called them "the Big Apple." Writer John J. Fitz Gerald popularized it in his columns.
Did jazz musicians really use the nickname?
Absolutely! For 1930s musicians, landing NYC gigs meant you'd "made it." The city paid better than anywhere, hence jazz slang like "playing the Apple" or "taking a bite out of the Big Apple."
Is there an official Big Apple landmark?
Yes! Visit "Big Apple Corner" at Broadway and 54th St (marked with a plaque). Nearby, the why New York City is called the Big Apple story is displayed at the Museum of the City of New York (1220 5th Ave).
How did the name survive the 20th century?
It nearly vanished twice. Jazz kept it alive in the 30s, and NYC's 1970s tourism campaign revived it using rediscovered newspaper clippings. Those "I ❤️ NY" apples? Direct descendants.
Do New Yorkers actually say "Big Apple"?
Less than tourists, but yes. You'll hear it in sports chants ("Let's go Big Apple!"), historical contexts, or with irony. Walk through Times Square and count how many souvenir shops use it!
Are there other nicknames for New York?
Dozens! "Gotham," "Empire City," "The City That Never Sleeps," but "Big Apple" uniquely captures its aspirational pull. That's why debating why New York City is called the Big Apple still matters.
The Cultural Impact Today
From Jay-Z lyrics to "Big Apple Circus" to those endless apple-shaped keychains, the nickname is everywhere. But my favorite modern twist? During the 2020 lockdown, artists projected giant glowing apples on empty landmarks – a symbol of resilience. That’s why even after learning why New York City is called the Big Apple, the name keeps evolving.
Last month, I saw a street vendor selling "Big Apple" t-shirts next to 1970s-style buttons. When I asked if customers knew the history, he laughed: "They just know it means New York, but sometimes I tell them about the horses." And that’s the point – it’s shorthand for everything this city represents. Whether you’re a tourist or a native, understanding why New York City is called the Big Apple gives you a slice of its soul.
Leave a Comments