Remember that time I tried dying my bright cherry red hair espresso brown? Let's just say it turned out more eggplant than chocolate. I stared at the mirror thinking "This ain't what the box showed." That disaster cost me $250 at a salon to fix. After that mess, I made it my mission to figure out this dying red hair darker thing properly.
Maybe you're tired of weekly touch-ups. Or your job needs more conservative colors. Or that vibrant red just doesn't match your mood anymore. Whatever your reason for darkening red hair, I get it. We'll cover everything – from picking shades that won't turn muddy to fixing botched jobs.
Why Darken Red Hair? Real Talk
Red hair demands attention. But maintaining that fire engine hue? Exhausting. Here's why folks shift gears:
- Upkeep fatigue: Fading starts around week two. Root regrowth screams at you by week three.
- Career shift (My lawyer friend got "the talk" about courtroom appropriateness)
- Seasonal mood: Summer vibrancy vs winter richness
- Dye damage control: Going darker often equals healthier strands
Truth moment? My first DIY attempt resulted in patchy burgundy splotches because I ignored my hair's porosity. Learn from my fail.
Before You Dye: Non-Negotiables
Grab a mirror. Let's diagnose your starting point:
Current Color Evaluation Chart
| Your Current Red | Darkening Challenges | Best Fix Approach |
|---|---|---|
| Bright copper/fire engine | Strong underlying warmth fights darkness | Pre-color filler mandatory |
| Auburn/medium red | Easier transition but risks muddiness | Use ash-based dyes carefully |
| Faded pinkish-red | Porous hair grabs color unevenly | Protein treatment before coloring |
| Previously bleached | High risk of greenish undertones | Demi-permanent first to test |
⚠️ Disaster Prevention Tip: Always strand test. That $5 savings isn't worth walking around with maroon-streaked hair for weeks. Ask how I know.
Color Selection: Navigating the Swatch Book
Drugstore aisles overwhelm. Avoid my mistake of grabbing "darkest brown" expecting miracles. Here's what works:
Shade Selection Cheat Sheet
Goal: Deep Auburn
Choose: Warm level 5 brown (e.g., "5WR" on box)
Skip: Neutral tones – they turn murky against red base
Goal: Chocolate Brown
Choose: Golden level 4 + dash of blue base (e.g., "4G" mixed with 1/4 "4B")
Why? Counters orange undertones without going green
Goal: Almost-Black
Choose: Blue-black (level 2-3) with 10 vol developer MAX
Critical: Pre-fill with red protein filler first!
Salon secret? We mix custom tones. For DIYers, brands like Redken Shades EQ offer more nuance than box dyes for dying red hair darker.
The Step-by-Step Darkening Process
Here's how I do it now after ruining two bath towels and a pillowcase:
- 72-hour patch test (seriously, don't skip)
- Pre-fill porous areas (ends! roots!) with protein filler
- Mix formula - Always measure developer-to-dye ratio
- Apply to mid-lengths first (most damaged)
- Work to roots last (heat processes faster there)
- Set timer for 20-25 minutes MAX
- Rinse with stupidly cold water until clear
The first time I did this right? Magic. No more brassy streaks.
Salon vs. DIY Cost & Outcome Comparison
| Approach | Average Cost | Processing Time | Best For | Downsides |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Professional Salon | $120-$350+ | 2-3 hours | Major transformations, corrective color | Pricey, requires booking |
| Box Dye (Drugstore) | $8-$15 | 45 mins | Small shade shifts, budget option | Limited color control, higher risk |
| Pro Dye (Sally Beauty) | $15-$25 | 60 mins | Precise formulations, longer-lasting | Requires knowledge of mixing |
Frankly? If going beyond two shades darker, spring for the salon. My botched DIY cost triple what a pro job would've.
Post-Dye Care: Locking In Darkness
New color fades fast if you treat it like regular hair. Here's what preserves it:
- Shampoo: Sulfate-free ONLY (try Matrix Total Results Dark Envy)
- Water temp: Lukewarm at hottest. Hot water opens cuticles.
- Gloss treatments: Every 3 weeks (Clairol Beautiful Collection works)
- Sun protection: Hat or UV spray (Sun Bum works well)
My lazy phase resulted in faded burgundy roots after 10 days. Don't be me.
Fix It Fast: Color Correction Tactics
So dying red hair darker went sideways? Common disasters:
Quick Fixes for Botched Jobs
Problem: Uneasy murky green
Cause: Ash dye over faded red
Fix: Red depositing conditioner (Keracolor Clenditioner) - leave on 15 mins
Problem: Hot roots
Cause: Applied color to roots first
Fix: Apply demi-permanent dye (match ends) to roots only for 5 mins
Problem: Patchy sections
Cause: Uneven porosity
Fix: Protein filler + diluted dye mixture applied ONLY to light spots
When in doubt? Call a salon. My "quick fix" once turned gray hair pink for a week.
Your Top Dying Red Hair Darker Questions
Will dark dye completely cover bright red?
Not always immediately. Vibrant red pigments are stubborn. Going gradually yields better results than one drastic jump.
Can I return to red after darkening?
Yes but it's a project. Dark dye must fade first. Use color removers, not bleach. Expect multiple sessions.
Why does my dark hair still look red?
Undertones! Neutralize with green-blue based dyes. But add sparingly - too much creates sludge color.
How long until I can recolor?
Wait 4-6 weeks minimum unless correcting. Fresh dye can't bond properly to freshly colored hair.
Best drugstore brand for darkening red?
Garnier Olia gets my vote. Oil-based formula doesn't dry hair. Avoid box blacks - they're flat.
Personal Product Hit List
After testing 20+ products:
- Budget MVP: Revlon Colorsilk (around $3)
- Mid-range: Redken Shades EQ (salon quality at Sally's)
- Splurge: Olaplex No.4P (purple shampoo that doesn't dry)
- Color Saver: BoldPunkt color depositing mask ($18 but lasts months)
That viral TikTok dye? Tried it. Turned my ends crusty. Stick with reputable brands.
The Real Timeline: What to Expect
Here's the unglamorous reality:
| Stage | Timeline | Maintenance Needed |
|---|---|---|
| Immediately After | Days 1-3 | Cold water rinses only, silk pillowcase |
| Initial Fade | Weeks 2-3 | First gloss treatment, sulfate-free wash |
| Noticeable Shift | Weeks 4-6 | Possible demi-permanent touch-up at roots |
| Complete Settling | Month 2+ | True color emerges as underlying pigments calm |
My hair took 5 weeks to stop looking artificially flat. Patience pays off when dying red hair darker.
Final Thoughts Before You Dye
Dying red hair darker seems simple until you're scrubbing dye off your forehead at 2am. Key takeaways:
- Darkening >3 levels? Go pro
- Porosity matters more than original color
- Ash = enemy, golden/blue = ally
- Maintenance starts BEFORE coloring
Last thing? Color remover doesn't belong in your bathroom unless you're trained. My curtains still have orange splatters as proof. Take it slow, strand test religiously, and embrace the process. That perfect deep merlot shade is worth the effort.
Leave a Comments