You know that feeling when you bite into a perfectly grilled steak at a great restaurant? That deep, savory, peppery crust that makes everything else fade away? Yeah, that magic. More often than not, it boils down to one hero: Montreal steak seasoning. But buying those little overpriced shakers? Forget it. Once you make your own homemade Montreal steak seasoning, seriously, you won't look back. It's pennies on the dollar, tastes infinitely fresher, and you control exactly what goes in. No mystery ingredients, no anti-caking agents. Just pure, unadulterated flavor power. And trust me, it makes a difference you can taste.
Why bother making it yourself? Look, store-bought stuff works in a pinch. I'll admit I've grabbed a bottle when desperate. But honestly? It often tastes dusty. Stale. Like the flavors lost their will to live somewhere in the warehouse. Your spices at home? Vibrant. Alive. Smelling them when you open your jars is half the joy. When you blend them fresh for your own DIY Montreal steak spice, it's a whole different league. The pepper crackles, the garlic punches, the paprika brings that warm glow. It just... sings.
What *Exactly* Makes Montreal Steak Seasoning...Montreal?
Okay, history lesson, but quick. This iconic blend isn't some ancient French secret. It burst onto the scene in Montreal’s Jewish delis decades ago, famous for their smoked meats. Think Schwartz's. They needed something bold enough to stand up to that intense smoky flavor. The classic profile? It's built on a few rockstars:
- Coarse Black Pepper: Not fine powder. We're talking big, bold, crunchy bits. This is the backbone, maybe 30-40% of the mix. It gives that signature bite.
- Coarse Salt: Usually kosher salt. Bigger crystals than table salt, so it doesn't dissolve instantly. It seasons deeply and provides texture.
- Garlic: Granulated or powder. Non-negotiable savory depth.
- Onion: Granulated or powder. Sweetness and more savory layers.
- Paprika: Sweet Hungarian paprika is classic. Smoked paprika? That's a modern twist I often sneak in for extra oomph. Adds color and subtle sweetness.
- Coriander: Crushed coriander seed. Citrusy, slightly floral. This is the subtle secret weapon people can't quite place but miss if it's gone.
- Dill: Dill seed, sometimes weed. Controversial! Some swear by it, others hate it. I like a touch of seed for a unique herbal note. Weed can be grassy.
- Red Pepper Flakes (Cayenne): Just enough heat to tickle the back of your throat, not blow your head off. Adjustable!
See, it's not magic dust. It's just really well-chosen, big-flavored stuff combined in a way that works perfectly on beef. The coarse grind is KEY. Fine powder just falls off the steak. You want those chunky bits to cling and create that amazing crust.
Building Your Ultimate Homemade Montreal Steak Seasoning: The Core Recipe
Alright, let's get mixing. This is my go-to base recipe. It's balanced, deeply savory with a peppery kick, and utterly addictive. Think of it as your sturdy foundation. You can tweak it endlessly later (and we will!).
The Essential Ingredient List & Why They Matter
| Ingredient | Amount | Type/Notes | Critical Role |
|---|---|---|---|
| Coarse Black Pepper | 1/4 cup | Tellicherry peppercorns freshly cracked are ideal (Peppercorn Medley works too) | Bold, spicy backbone & signature crunch |
| Coarse Kosher Salt | 3 tablespoons | Diamond Crystal brand preferred for consistency (Morton's is saltier - use 2.5 tbsp) | Deep seasoning, texture, helps form crust |
| Granulated Garlic | 2 tablespoons | NOT garlic powder (finer, burns easier). Granulated gives better texture. | Savoury depth, umami punch |
| Granulated Onion | 1 tablespoon | Same as garlic - granulated over powder. | Sweetness, complexity, savoury base |
| Sweet Paprika | 2 tablespoons | Hungarian sweet paprika preferred for vibrant color & mild flavor | Color, subtle sweetness, warmth |
| Crushed Coriander Seed | 2 teaspoons | Whole seeds lightly crushed in mortar/pestle or spice grinder (pulse!) | Citrusy, complex floral note (secret flavour enhancer) |
| Dill Seed | 1.5 teaspoons | NOT dill weed. Seeds have a caraway-like, savory flavor. | Unique herbal backbone (classic Montreal touch) |
| Crushed Red Pepper Flakes | 1 teaspoon | OR Cayenne pepper for pure heat (adjust to taste) | Gentle background heat, balances richness |
Making It: More Than Just Dumping Spices
Gathering the ingredients is step one. How you combine them matters almost as much.
- Grind Smart, Not Fine: This isn't dust. For the black pepper and coriander seed, you WANT texture. Use a dedicated coffee grinder (clean!), pepper mill on coarse setting, or mortar and pestle. Pulse briefly. You're looking for mostly 1-2mm pieces with some finer bits. Over-grinding is the enemy of good homemade Montreal steak seasoning texture.
- Mix Thoroughly, But Gently: Combine all ingredients in a medium bowl. Use a whisk or fork. Seriously, take a minute here. You want every scoop to get every flavor.
- Store Like Gold: Air and light are flavor killers. Dump your amazing mix into an airtight container. Glass jar best, opaque if possible. Mason jars work great. Keep it in a cool, dark cupboard. Not next to the stove or oven!
That smell? Pure steakhouse anticipation.
How long does it last? Honestly, the flavors peak in the first 2-3 months. It's still safe after 6 months, but the vibrancy fades. That's why making small-ish batches (this recipe fills a decent-sized spice jar) is smart. You'll use it faster than you think.
Texture Tip: If your salt is finer than kosher (like table salt), reduce the amount slightly (start with 2 tbsp) and maybe add an extra pinch of coarse pepper to compensate texture-wise. Fine salt can make it taste saltier faster.
Level Up: Tweaking Your Homemade Blend Like a Pro
The base recipe rocks. But maybe black pepper isn't your absolute favorite? Or you love smoke? This is where DIY Montreal steak spice shines. Make it YOURS.
Popular Flavor Twists & Customizations
- Smoke Show: Swap 1 tablespoon of the sweet paprika for smoked paprika. Or add 1/2 teaspoon of ground chipotle pepper. Gives that backyard BBQ vibe without the grill. (My personal favorite tweak).
- Heat Seeker: Double the red pepper flakes or cayenne. Add 1/4 teaspoon of ground ghost pepper if you're brave (and warn your guests!).
- Umami Bomb: Add 1 tablespoon of dried porcini mushroom powder (grind dried mushrooms super fine). Deep, earthy savoriness. Amazing on ribeyes.
- Citrus Zing: Add the finely grated zest of 1 lemon or orange (dried zest works too, but fresh is brighter). Mixes beautifully with the coriander.
- Herb Garden: Add 1 teaspoon dried rosemary (crumbled very fine) or thyme. Rosemary pairs especially well with beef.
- Less Dill, More...: Not a dill fan? Reduce or omit the dill seed. Replace it with a pinch more coriander or even a 1/4 teaspoon celery seed.
Ingredient Quality Matters (A Lot)
Here's the uncomfortable truth: Garbage in, garbage out. If your spices have been sitting in the cupboard since the last Olympics, your homemade Montreal steak seasoning will taste flat. Old paprika loses its vibrancy and turns bitter. Stale pepper? Just dusty heat.
Buying Tips:
- **Check Dates:** Look for "Best By" or "Packaged On" dates. Fresher is better.
- **Smaller Quantities:** Buy from bulk bins or stores with high turnover (ethnic markets are often great). You use less per batch, so you can afford better quality.
- **Whole vs Ground:** Whenever possible, buy whole peppercorns, coriander seeds, dill seeds. Grind them fresh. The difference is night and day.
- **Paprika Power:** Splurge on good Hungarian sweet paprika. It should be bright red, not rusty brown. Smoked paprika quality varies wildly too – find one you like the aroma of.
Old spices are budget killers, not savers.
Using Your Homemade Montreal Steak Seasoning: Beyond Just Steak
Okay, you've got this jar of awesome. How do you unleash it properly? It's easy to overdo it or underdo it.
Applying It Right for Perfect Results
For Steak (Ribeye, Strip, Sirloin, Flank, Hanger):
- Pat Dry: CRITICAL. Take your steak out of the fridge, unwrap it, and pat it SUPER dry with paper towels. Moisture is the enemy of searing and spice adhesion.
- Oil Lightly (Optional but Recommended): Brush or rub a *thin* layer of neutral oil (canola, grapeseed, avocado) on the steak. This helps the spices stick and promotes browning.
- Season Generously, Press In: Sprinkle your homemade Montreal steak seasoning liberally over all sides. Don't be shy! Press it gently into the meat with your fingers so it adheres well. You want a visible, even coating.
- Rest Briefly: Let the seasoned steak sit at room temperature for 20-45 minutes before cooking. This lets the salt start working into the meat and helps the spices hydrate slightly, reducing the chance of burning.
Burn Notice: Because garlic and onion powder can scorch at high heat, ensure your grill/pan isn't *too* crazy hot when you start. Medium-high is usually safer than screaming hot for heavily seasoned steaks. Sear hard, but watch for blackening spices before the steak is cooked.
Cooking Methods That Shine
- Grilling (Gas or Charcoal): The classic. Preheat grill to medium-high. Grill steaks to desired doneness, flipping only once or twice. Those coarse spices will char beautifully.
- Cast Iron Skillet: My weeknight favorite. Heat skillet over medium-high heat until very hot. Add a tiny bit of high-smoke oil. Sear steak hard on both sides, then finish in a 400°F (200°C) oven if thick.
- Broiling: Great for thinner cuts. Position rack so top of steak is 3-4 inches from broiler element. Broil 4-7 mins per side depending on thickness.
That sizzle? Music.
Beyond the Steak: Seriously, Use This Stuff Everywhere
This blend isn't just for steak. It's a savory powerhouse:
- Burgers: Mix 1-2 tablespoons per pound of ground beef. Game changer.
- Roasts: Rub it all over a chuck roast, tri-tip, or pork tenderloin before roasting.
- Chicken: Excellent on chicken thighs (skin-on!), breasts, or wings.
- Potatoes: Toss potato wedges or cubes with oil and a generous sprinkle before roasting.
- Vegetables: Sprinkle on grilled zucchini, asparagus, or portobello mushrooms.
- Popcorn: Sounds weird? Try a light dusting with melted butter. Salty, savory bliss.
- Eggs: Sprinkle on scrambled eggs or an omelette for a kick.
Storing Your Masterpiece: Keeping the Flavor Alive
You put effort into this. Don't ruin it with bad storage!
- Airtight is Non-Negotiable: Glass jar with a tight-sealing lid is ideal. Mason jars are perfect. Plastic containers *can* work short-term but aren't as good long-term.
- Darkness Wins: Light degrades spices fast. Keep the jar in a closed cupboard, away from the stove or any window.
- Cool & Dry: Heat and moisture are enemies. Pantry is best. Not above the dishwasher or fridge (heat/humidity).
- Label & Date: Write "Homemade Montreal Steak Seasoning" and the date you made it. Trust me, you'll forget.
Shelf Life Reality Check: At peak flavor for about 3 months. Still usable for up to 6 months, but the vibrancy (especially the pepper and paprika) diminishes noticeably. That's why making manageable batches is key. It's so cheap and easy, just make more!
DIY Montreal Steak Seasoning - Frequently Asked Questions (Real Ones!)
Is making homemade Montreal steak seasoning actually cheaper?
Hands down, yes. The upfront cost for jars of spices might seem like $15-20, but remember: you use maybe $1-2 worth per batch, and that batch gives you way more seasoning than a $6-8 store bottle. Over time, refilling your core spices (pepper, salt, paprika, garlic) is super cheap.
Can I use regular table salt instead of coarse kosher salt?
You *can*, but I really don't recommend it. Table salt is much finer and denser. If you use the same volume (like 3 tablespoons), it will make your homemade Montreal steak seasoning WAY too salty. If you must, use HALF the amount of table salt (about 1.5 tablespoons for this recipe) and expect less texture.
My spices seemed to burn on the steak before it was cooked through. What happened?
Two common culprits: 1) Your heat was too high. Garlic and onion powders scorch easily. Try medium-high instead of high. Patience wins. 2) You used garlic/onion *powder* (not granulated). Powders are finer and burn even faster. Granulated is essential for grilling/broiling. Also, ensure you patted the steak bone dry!
Why does my homemade blend taste bitter?
Oh, this is frustrating! Usually, it's one of three things: 1) **Old Paprika:** Paprika turns bitter as it oxidizes. Freshen up your supply. 2) **Burnt Spices During Cooking:** See above. 3) **Over-Ground Pepper/Coriander:** If you pulverized the pepper/coriander into dust, it can release bitter compounds, especially if cooked too hot. Coarse is key!
Can I make it without dill? I hate dill.
Absolutely! The dill seed (not weed) is traditional but not universally loved. Simply omit it. The blend will still be fantastic. You could add a tiny pinch more coriander or a touch of celery seed if you like, but it's not necessary.
Is this seasoning blend gluten-free? Vegan?
Yes and yes! When you make your own homemade Montreal steak seasoning, you know exactly what's in it: spices and salt. No hidden gluten, MSG, dairy, sugar, or animal products. Always check labels on individual spice bottles if you have severe allergies, but pure spices are inherently GF and vegan.
Can I grind everything super fine for a rub?
Technically? Sure. But you lose the defining characteristic. The coarse texture clings beautifully and creates that incredible crusty, crunchy exterior on the steak. Fine powder mostly falls off or burns instantly. Stick to coarse!
Where's the best place to buy the spices affordably?
Bulk bins at stores like WinCo, Sprouts, or local co-ops are winners. You buy exactly what you need. Ethnic grocery stores (Mexican, Indian, Middle Eastern) often have incredibly fresh spices at great prices. Online retailers like Penzeys or The Spice House offer high quality but cost a bit more.
The Real Deal: Why Homemade Crushes Store-Bought Every Time
Let's be brutally honest. That famous yellow-capped bottle? It's... fine. It gets the job done. But once you taste your own homemade Montreal steak seasoning? There's no comparison.
- Taste: Fresher, brighter, more complex. The flavors are distinct, not muddled. You taste the pepper, the garlic, the subtle coriander.
- Texture: That satisfying coarse crunch is way more pronounced in homemade versions. Store-bought often feels finer, almost sandy.
- Control: Less salt? More heat? Extra smoke? Done. You're the boss. Hate dill? Gone.
- Cost: Way cheaper per ounce. Significantly.
- Purity: No anti-caking agents, no preservatives, no weird fillers. Just spices and salt.
- Satisfaction: There's a genuine pride in sprinkling your own blend. It tastes better because you made it.
That first bite of steak seasoned with your own mix? Pure triumph.
Making your own homemade Montreal steak seasoning isn't just about saving money or avoiding additives. It's about unlocking a level of flavor and satisfaction you simply can't buy off a shelf. Five minutes of mixing, a jar in the cupboard, and suddenly, every steak night feels like a special occasion. Give it a shot. Your grill (and your taste buds) will thank you.
Leave a Comments