Man, if you're diving into Bills vs Dolphins history, you're in for a wild ride. These two teams hate each other - and I mean that in the best football way possible. It's not just division rivals going through the motions. This rivalry has ice storms, bench-clearing brawls, and comebacks that'll make your jaw drop. I remember freezing my butt off at Orchard Park in '93 watching Dan Marino fake spike the ball for a last-second touchdown. Still makes me mad!
The Early Years: How It All Started
Let's rewind to the beginning. Both teams joined the AFL in the 60s - Dolphins in 1966, Bills in 1960. Their first meeting? September 23, 1966. Dolphins squeaked out a 16-14 win. Back then, nobody knew this would become one of football's most heated rivalries.
What fueled the fire? Geography for starters. Buffalo's freezing winters vs Miami's beach weather. Players actually complained about traveling between these cities. Dolphins legend Dick Anderson once said playing in Buffalo felt like "getting hit with frozen rocks."
Funny thing about the early Bills vs Dolphins history...
The Dolphins dominated at first. From 1970-79, they went 15-5 against the Bills. Why? Two words: Miami's perfect season in '72. That team crushed Buffalo twice by a combined 64-17. Ouch.
The Glory Years (And Some Painful Memories)
The 80s and 90s? That's when this rivalry exploded. Jim Kelly vs Dan Marino became must-watch TV. I still get chills thinking about those shootouts. December 1981 was iconic - Dolphins won 31-28 in OT after Buffalo tied it with 11 seconds left. The stadium noise was unreal.
But let's talk about the game that still haunts Bills fans. December 17, 1994. Marino's fake spike. With 22 seconds left, down 4, at the Bills 8-yard line. Marino yells "Clock!" like he's spiking it... then throws a TD to Mark Ingram. Pure heartbreak for Buffalo. I watched it at a Buffalo sports bar and let me tell you - the silence was louder than any cheer.
Why This Era Mattered
Both teams were stacked with Hall of Famers:
- Buffalo: Kelly, Thomas, Reed, Smith
- Miami: Marino, Stephenson, Duper, Clayton
They played 8 times from 1990-94 with playoff implications every game. That's unheard of now.
The Ugly Moments (Because Every Rivalry Has Them)
Not all Bills vs Dolphins history is glorious. Remember that nasty brawl in 1998? Bruce Smith threw a punch, Ted Washington body-slammed a guy - total chaos. Six players got ejected. Honestly? Kinda embarrassing for both sides.
And the weather games! The 2003 season finale was played in a blizzard. You couldn't see yard lines. Dolphins won 17-7 despite completing ONE pass. Watching that mess, I wondered why they didn't postpone it.
Head-to-Head Stats That'll Shock You
People always ask "Who leads the Bills vs Dolphins series?" Here's the full breakdown through 2023:
| Category | Bills Lead | Dolphins Lead | Ties |
|---|---|---|---|
| Regular Season Wins | 62 | 61 | 1 |
| Playoff Wins | 1 | 2 | 0 |
| Total Points Scored | 2,266 | 2,252 | - |
| Biggest Win Margin | Bills 42-0 (1966) | Dolphins 56-26 (1995) | - |
That single tie? A 22-22 mess in 1967 where both kickers missed game-winners. My dad was there - he says fans threw so many snowballs the refs threatened to forfeit the game.
The Quarterback Carousel
Want to understand Bills vs Dolphins history? Follow the QBs. It reads like a who's who of football:
Miami Greats: Griese (1967-80) • Marino (1983-99) • Fiedler (2000-04) • Tannehill (2012-18) • Tua (2020-present)
Buffalo Gunslingers: Kemp (1962-69) • Ferguson (1973-84) • Kelly (1986-96) • Bledsoe (2002-04) • Allen (2018-present)
Personal opinion? Kelly vs Marino was peak entertainment. But today's Allen vs Tua battles feel like they're reviving that magic. Check out their head-to-head stats:
| Quarterback | Record vs Opponent | TD Passes | INTs | Passer Rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Josh Allen (BUF) | 8-2 vs MIA | 26 | 5 | 106.7 |
| Tua Tagovailoa (MIA) | 1-6 vs BUF | 15 | 8 | 81.2 |
Random fact: Doug Flutie started more games against Miami (6) than any other Bills QB except Kelly. And Flutie always played weirdly well against them!
Games That Defined Bills vs Dolphins History
Some matchups just stick with you. Here are five that shaped Bills vs Dolphins history:
- 1971 AFC Divisional: Dolphins win 27-10 in Miami's first playoff game ever. Mercury Morris ran for 94 yards and a TD. Still hurts Bills fans who thought their defense could stop them.
- The Snowplow Game (1982): Not Bills-Dolphins but relevant. A snowplow cleared a spot for Miami's kicker to beat New England. Buffalo fans swear that plow operator cost them a division title.
- Marino's Fake Spike (1994): Already mentioned but too iconic to skip. Changed how teams manage clock situations forever.
- The Miami Miracle (2018): Dolphins pull off 69-yard lateral play with 0:00 on clock to win 34-33. Bills corner Levi Wallace told me later: "We practiced that play all week and STILL blew it."
- Allen's 4-TD Comeback (2022): Bills trailed 21-7 in Miami. Allen goes nuts with 4 TDs including 3 in final 18 minutes. Stadium security said Miami fans left silently "like they saw a ghost."
Where Things Stand Today
Recent Bills vs Dolphins history feels lopsided. Buffalo's won 9 of last 10 meetings. Why? Three reasons:
- Josh Allen is a Miami nightmare
- Buffalo's defense makes Tua uncomfortable
- AFC East has flipped from Miami's dominance
But don't count Miami out. Their 2023 70-burger against Denver showed offensive firepower. And that Week 4 win over Buffalo last season? Proved they can hang when healthy.
What's next? Probably more shootouts. Both teams have young offensive weapons:
New Generation Stars
Buffalo: James Cook (RB) • Dalton Kincaid (TE) • Khalil Shakir (WR)
Miami: Jaylen Waddle (WR) • De'Von Achane (RB) • Jalen Ramsey (CB)
FAQs About Bills vs Dolphins History
Q: What's the longest win streak in the series?
A: Dolphins won 20 straight from 1970-79. Bills fans still call this "The Dark Decade."
Q: Has either team swept a season series recently?
A: Buffalo swept in 2019, 2020, and 2021. Before that? Miami swept in 2016 and 2017.
Q: Who owns the record for most passing yards in a Bills-Dolphins game?
A: Ryan Fitzpatrick threw for 337 yards for Buffalo in 2011 loss. Fittingly, he later played for Miami too.
Q: Which stadium has hosted the most Bills vs Dolphins games?
A: Miami's Hard Rock Stadium (formerly Joe Robbie) with 51 meetings. Orchard Park hosted 50.
Final Thoughts From a Football Junkie
After following Bills vs Dolphins history for 30 years, here's my take: This rivalry works because both fanbases care deeply. It's not manufactured. You've got blue-collar Buffalo vs flashy Miami. Cold vs heat. Wings vs cuban sandwiches.
The stats show how even it's been overall (62-61-1). Yet each era feels different. The 70s Dolphins dominance. The 90s QB duels. Today's offensive fireworks. Through it all? Mutual respect wrapped in hatred.
Will Buffalo's current run continue? Maybe. But remember - in Bills vs Dolphins history, momentum shifts like Lake Erie winds. One big Tua-to-Hill connection could change everything. That's why we watch.
What's your favorite Bills-Dolphins moment? Mine's still Thurman Thomas rushing for 158 yards in that '90 playoff win. Pure poetry in shoulder pads.
Leave a Comments